- Water was coming into the TV den inside the balcony, and also the studio below
- We had to remove tons of stone to solve balcony issues as builder did nothing
- Builder only tightened door seal, left after hearing of high moisture meter readings
- 14-ft Tyvek gap among many, despite Beau Rutherford’s testimony under oath
Water was coming into the TV den inside the balcony, and also the studio below
Issue: At the balcony, water was entering the TV den, warping and cupping the hickory/pecan floor. Also, water was coming out of drywall around two windows in the studio below the balcony. The builder took no action to solve the balcony problems.
How our Rutherford Custom Home balcony was built (revealed in deconstruction):
- built the balcony floor too high
- used metal flashing too short to direct water away from the home
- used metal flashing that directed water behind stone down to the unflashed windows below, where it came out onto the studio floor
- allowed two large holes in the metal flashing, one on each side of the door to the TV den, where water had been coming onto the hickory/pecan floor.
- used metal flashing only half the balcony width
- left a 14-foot-wide gap in the Tyvek Home Wrap where the balcony joined the home
- ignored architect’s report (with photos) that called for ensuring Tyvek continuity, and for sealing Tyvek gaps
James W. Rutherford, Jr.’s, deposition testimony on the major balcony problems:
Q: Did you have an opportunity to inspect that balcony at the time of its construction to ensure that it was adequately flashed so as to prevent water penetrating the inside of the house?
A: Yes, sir.
Q: You did inspect it?
Q: And it met your approval?
A: It did.
We had to remove tons of stone to solve balcony issues as builder did nothing
When we walked onto the just-hardened concrete foundation at the start of construction, we had a view to the south and asked if we could add a small balcony. Yes, we were told. The architect got plans to the builder quickly, during framing.
The balcony as built, however, directed water into the TV den’s hickory/pecan floor, destroying it, and into the wall and studio below, coming through drywall around the unflashed windows.
The balcony did not have proper metal flashing. Deconstruction photos showed clearly that the metal flashing would direct water into the wall rather than away from the home. Beau Rutherford testified that he inspected the balcony and it met his approval. (See display quote.)
During construction, we pointed out by phone to Jim Rutherford that water was on the studio floor and appeared to be coming out of the wall from the windows under the balcony. We added it to the 9/22/08 To Do list, which was still during construction. Rutherford Custom Homes either took no action or took ineffectual action to fix the water intrusion. The floor, however, was cleaned up after the leak.
Builder only tightened door seal, left after hearing of high moisture meter readings
6/4/09 – On “To Do” list, tv den door to balcony would not open, blocked by the greatly warped wood threshold. The hickory/pecan floor below the threshold was cupped. Rutherfords said they’d sand down the bottom of the threshold board and that would fix the problem. They did not address the cupped floor. Wanting an opinion on the cause of the problem, we called out the flooring store.
6/25/09 – The floor representative’s moisture meter showed very heavy water in the TV den floor inside the balcony, but also in the living/dining room. And a deeper-reading meter showed heavy moisture in the subfloor.
6/25/09 – We again showed Beau and Jim Rutherford the problem areas and shared the major water intrusion information. Beau Rutherford attributed the water damage to door seals and tightened the living room and balcony doors but offered nothing to fix the TV den floor beyond sanding down the balcony threshold.
6/4/09 – 7/16/09 — Rutherford Custom Homes’ did nothing about our widespread wood floor problem or the problem with the balcony. They’d already sent someone twice to check 15 leaking windows but they were not fixed (they sent not the windows framer, but a person who didn’t know that behind stone and Hardiplank, the windows were not flashed), someone to fix the roof (still leaking), painters to correct problems (they never finished the job), and now the balcony and wood floor had problems. Our problems were spreading and getting larger. We could not reach Rutherford Custom Homes as no one was answering the office phone. We tried their cell phones, then their home phone. We also tried email but never got a response. We terminated Rutherford Custom Homes in late July, 2009.
Sept. 17-20, 2009 – Two months after terminating the builder and trying to find what the TV den water and studio below water had in common, we decided to check the balcony. Tons of stone wall were removed above and below the balcony, revealing critical balcony defects that directed water into studio wall and TV den, where it destroyed a portion of the hickory/pecan floor.
14-ft Tyvek gap among many, despite Beau Rutherford’s testimony under oath
Q: With respect to the application of the Tyvek to the exterior of the house, do you recall inspecting the application of the Tyvek prior to it being covered with stone or wood?
A: Yes, sir.
Q: And did it pass your inspection?
A: Yes, sir.
Q: And was it properly taped around the windows and doors and every place to your satisfaction?
A: Yes, sir.